Grilled New York Strip with Herb Butter

New York strip steaks grilled over high heat and topped with a slice of parsley, chive, garlic and lemon compound butter that melts into a sauce. Serves 4.

Naturally gluten-freeKetoLow-carbHigh-proteinNo added sugar

Contains: milk. Based on the ingredients as written; check package labels, which can change.

  • Prep 15 min
  • Cook 10 min
  • Chill butter and rest 35 min
  • Total 1 hr
  • Yield 4 servings
  • Level Intermediate

Updated

Two grilled New York strip steaks topped with herb butter on a wooden board, one sliced medium-rare

The New York strip is a classic grilling steak: tender, beefy and easy to cook evenly because of its even shape. Here it gets nothing more than salt and pepper and a hot grill, then a slice of homemade herb butter as it rests.

Compound butter is just softened butter mixed with herbs, garlic and lemon, rolled into a log and chilled. It keeps for a week in the refrigerator or months in the freezer, so make extra for vegetables, fish and bread.

Instructions

  1. Make the herb butter. Mash together the butter, parsley, chives, garlic, lemon zest and salt. Spoon it onto plastic wrap, roll it into a log about 1 inch thick, twist the ends and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes.
  2. Season the steaks. Pat the steaks dry and season both sides with the salt and pepper. Let them sit while the grill heats.
  3. Heat the grill. Heat a gas grill to high or build a hot charcoal fire. Clean the grate and wipe it with an oiled paper towel.
  4. Grill. Rub the steaks lightly with oil and grill over direct high heat for 4 to 5 minutes per side for medium-rare, turning once. Rotate them 45 degrees halfway through each side if you want crosshatch marks.
  5. Check doneness. Remove the steaks at 125°F for medium-rare or 135°F for medium, measured in the center.
  6. Rest with butter. Move the steaks to a platter, top each with a 1/2-inch slice of herb butter, and let them rest for 5 minutes while it melts.

Nutrition per serving (estimated)

870Calories
0 gCarbohydrates
0 gFiber
0 gNet carbs
63 gProtein
67 gFat

Estimated per serving, based on 4 servings, using USDA FoodData Central values for each ingredient. Net carbs are carbohydrates minus fiber. Optional ingredients, garnishes and anything served on the side are not included, and marinades are counted at about a third because most is discarded. Brands and portion sizes change the numbers.

KetoLow-carbHigh-proteinGluten-freeGrill and BBQNo added sugar

Tips

  • Score the fat strip along the edge every inch or so to keep the steak from curling on the grill.
  • If flare-ups char the steak, move it briefly to a cooler part of the grill.
  • Blue cheese, roasted garlic or chipotle butters are easy variations.

Storage and leftovers

Refrigerate sliced steak up to 4 days. Warm slices for 30 seconds in a hot pan, or serve cold in a steak salad. The herb butter log keeps 1 week in the refrigerator or 3 months in the freezer.

Questions about this recipe

How long do you grill a 1-inch strip steak?
Over high heat, about 4 to 5 minutes per side for medium-rare and 5 to 6 minutes per side for medium.
What is compound butter?
It is softened butter mixed with flavorings such as herbs, garlic, citrus or spices, then chilled and sliced. It melts over hot food into an instant sauce.
Is New York strip the same as sirloin?
No. The strip comes from the short loin and is more tender. Top sirloin is cut from just behind it and is leaner and less expensive.

Serve it with

Pairs with: Cabernet Sauvignon or Malbec. Wine pairing guide

More beef and steak recipes